Can't really give a rating until I've worn them for a year and see how they hold up. Might rate higher a year from now. They appear to be well built but time will tell. Nice to see American made boots. They are still not the boots they used to make that were uncomfortable as hell for a week until you wore them in and could be re-soled a couple of times before you had to throw them out. Those were durable. Nobody seems to make those anymore. Todays Chinese made boots are junk.A couple of minor design critiques: There are only 3 pairs of lace hooks on the boots. 4 would have been better. The space between the last pair of eyes and the first hooks is too large. That area is tough to get tight and it allows your heel to move around a bit. The side flaps (probably not the correct boot terminology) should be shortened up a to spread the eyes out a little bit. That would also help to tighten the laces.
I felt this product's fit was
Fits true to size
I felt this product's width was
Fits true to width